TAG | web browsers
10
Battle of the Netbook Web Browsers: Javascript Performance Benchmark on a Hackintosh Laptop
After the first Battle of the Netbook Web Browsers on my Dell Mini 10v hackintosh, I’ve switched over from Safari to Google Chrome as my default web browser on all the Macs I have at home. Why, you may ask? Well, I have two reasons for changing.
First, I really like the integrated address bar and search box in Google Chrome. It simplifies the two things I do most in the web browser, surfing and searching. I can just type a URL or search criteria in the same place.
Second, performance. Google Chrome somehow felt snappier compared to the other browsers. So, I decided to confirm what I felt by running a performance test with the different web browsers on my Mini 10v laptop.
The Performance Test Suite
I decided on using the Dromaeo Javascript Performance Test Suite after trying out two other JavaScript performance benchmark, SunSpider and Peacekeeper. Dromaeo is comprehensive yet simple to execute. It is made up of Javascript and DOM tests created by the Dromaeo, Webkit, V8 and MooTools team. The test suite also includes DOM test for the jQuery, Prototype, Dojo, MooTools, YUI and ExtJS javascript libraries.
The full Dromaeo Performance Test runs for an estimated 33 mins 40 seconds on the web browser. The fastest web browser will be the one that executes the most test runs per second. So, which web browser is the fastest?
The Test Results
Google Chrome wins the web browser performance trophy on my Dell Mini 10v. It finished in the top spot slightly ahead of Safari. The slowest web browser? Camino. It’s time for me to remove Camino from my laptop. Apart from being slow, it has nothing special. I don’t see any reason why anyone would want to use Camino.
Dromaeo stores a copy the detailed score of each web browser tested. You can check out the details with the links below.
- Safari 4.0.3
- Firefox 3.5.3
- Google Chrome 4.0.221
- Opera 10
- Camino 1.6.10
- Comparing Safari (WebKit/531.9), Firefox (Firefox/3.5.3) and Google Chrome(WebKit/532.2).
The Conclusion
The test confirms that Google Chrome is the fastest web browser on my hackintosh laptop. I will continue to have Google Chrome as my default web browser.
But the truth is for most people, they will not sense the performance difference between the browsers tested. The bottleneck is usually with the internet connection rather than javascript performance. Just keep using whichever web browser that fits your browsing style.
As for me, I’m very happy with Google Chrome. Google Chrome full screen view and performance ROCKS on the Mini 10v hackintosh laptop.
5
Battle of the Netbook Web Browsers: Safari vs Firefox vs Camino vs Chrome vs Opera on a Hackintosh Laptop
3 Comments | Posted by Victor Goh in Mac OS X, Review
I use my Dell Mini 10v hackintosh mainly to get online and surf the Internet. As a hackintosh laptop user, I get to use Safari as my default web browser. Apart from Safari, I have installed four ‘other’ web browsers on my hackintosh laptop. These ‘other’ web browsers are Firefox, Google Chrome, Camino and Opera. With so many web browsers available for the Mac OS X, which is the best web browser for my hackintosh laptop? To find the answer, I did a comparison between these 5 web browsers, to find the one I like the most.
The Best Web Browser For A Netbook Challenge
The Dell Mini 10v display resolution is only 1024×600 pixels. This is the standard display resolution for most netbooks available today. The netbook display resolution is of course, smaller compared to the popular 1280×800 resolution for entry-level laptops. Because of the smaller screen, my most important web browser feature is the ability to view web pages in full screen view. I have to make every pixel count. I also want to have easy keyboard shortcuts for navigating between tabs. I prefer using the keyboard instead of the tiny Mini 10v trackpad.
The Criteria For the Winning Netbook Web Browser
- Full Screen Mode – The web browser must be able to display web pages in full screen view. It should be easy to switch between full screen and normal view using the keyboard.
- Keyboard Shortcuts – Secondly, it must be easy to navigate between web pages and open new tabs using the keyboard only.
Since all the web browsers support keyboard shortcuts, I’m going to focus my testing on the full screen viewing capabilities of the various web browsers.
The Five Candidates
The surprising thing is, not all Mac OS X web browsers support full screen view. For those that don’t, I hid the address, bookmark and status bar to optimize the view for the browser window. Below are screenshots of the five web browsers with their default view and their full screen or optimized view.
1. Safari 4
The address and bookmark bar together with the Mac OS X menu bar and title bar takes up one big chunk of space. Hiding the address and bookmark bar as shown in the optimized view will reclaim around 50 pixels in height.
Safari Default View
Safari Optimized View
2. Firefox 3.5
The address and bookmark bar in Firefox takes up even more space compared to Safari. When the address and bookmark bar is hidden, the view is the same as Safari optimized view.
Firefox Default View
Firefox Optimized View
3. Camino 1.6
The default Camino view has bigger icons in the address bar and so takes up more space compared to Firefox and Safari address bar. After removing the address and bookmark bar, Camino optimized view is still a few pixels smaller compared to Firefox and Safari. There’s no option to hide the Camino status bar in the menu.
Camino Default View
Camino Optimized View
4. Google Chrome 4
Google Chrome default view doesn’t come with a bookmark bar and has the biggest space for the web page among the browsers tested. In the full screen view, with Chrome address bar and tabs removed together with Mac OS X menu and browser title bar, 94 pixels or an additional 15% of the screen height is available to display the web page.
Google Chrome Default View
Google Chrome Full Screen View
5. Opera 10
Opera default view has slightly more screen space compared to the default Camino and Firefox view. When in full screen view, it is the same as Google Chrome full screen view.
Opera Default View
Opera Full Screen View
The Champion of the Netbook Web Browsers Battle
The champion for our Netbook Web Browsers battle is undoubtedly Google Chrome. Google Chrome full screen view with toggling by keyboard makes it the winner in the battle of the netbook browsers. Opera 10 comes in at second place with full screen mode too but without keyboard toggling for full screen view. To toggle full screen view on Opera requires using the touchpad with the Menu or Context Menu.
Update: Both Google Chrome and Opera 10 has full screen view with keyboard shortcuts. They are both champions in our battle of the hackintosh netbook web browsers. Earlier, I declared Google Chrome as the winner because I thought it was the only browser with keyboard shortcuts for full screen view, but since then, I’ve found the full screen view keyboard shortcut for Opera. Option+F11 on Opera Mac OS X will toggle full screen view. (Thanks goes to Rijk, for the tip).
For the browsers doesn’t support full screen mode, the next best thing is to turn off or hide the address, bookmarks and status bar of the browser. This will give the maximum viewing space for the web page. Setting the Mac OS X dock to auto-hide will also save some space.
The Aftermath
I was disappointed to discover Safari, Firefox and Camino doesn’t have full screen view on the Mac OS X.
I am now using Google Chrome as the default web browser for my hackintosh laptop because of its full screen view. Google Chrome also seems faster compared to the other web browsers.
The next battle of the web browsers will be based on performance. I will conduct a performance benchmark to compare the various web browsers on my Dell Mini 10v. Come back soon to check out the benchmark results.
